This Forum has been archived

Visit Discussions
Forums: Index > Questions > Could Silver be related to Sonic?

A whole lot of people (including me) think that Silver might be Sonic's descendant, does anybody else think thats true? Jrgumban 11:00, 28 January 2009

The only evidense to support the relation is that they look a like, though most hedgehogs seem to share common traits like cycloptic eyes that always look serious. Even all Hedgehog fan characters look a like since they are originally based on Sonic, heck we could say Mighty can be related to Sonic when all they have in relation is that Mighty was Sonic's Beta design. Eitherway there maybe more evidense I have overlooked that point to Sonic and Silver being related.--Mystic Monkey 22:39, 28 January 2009 (UTC)

The games have Sonic and Amy dating. Therefore, in time, you can expect to see their kids. Silver might be the kids kid, or one of those kids. From a design point of view, Silver's spines look like Amy's slightly. There are tonnes of ideas being thrown around, but the other forum has mine in there with massive detail. Flashfire212 06:24, 29 January 2009 (UTC)

Another point of evidence that they 'could' be related is that Silver seems to share a lot of Sonic's personality, like his strong sence of justice as well as his somewhat imature personality, then theres also the fact that they both seem to refuse to leave a person in trouble. Jrgumban 08:25, 29 January 2009 (UTC)

Perhaps Silver is a clever ploy, a sort of "nudge" towards SonAmy, or oerhaps Son??? but who can say? Thats what makes it interesting is that we are not sure.--Mystic Monkey 01:48, 30 January 2009 (UTC)

I thought that Silver being Sonic's kid was confermed. Flashfire212 23:55, 1 February 2009 (UTC)

i dotn think silver ir sonic kid cuz if he was. he would be tryign to kill his own father in Sonic 06. and if he was his son he would be like oh teh noes my father is the destrotor of the world

Okay first, you're spelling is horrible, second, do you by chance know who you're great great great great grandfather is, if not, consider rethinking what you wrote, I mean really, everybody knows that sonic can't be Silver's father but they may be related. Jrgumban 13:35, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

Yah a 1350 year gap I believe, At least if Silver knew Eggman Nega who claimed to be from the future then it fits in with Next-Gen, I just wish sonic Team would make up it's mind between Time/Space.--Mystic Monkey 15:34, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

Ok Sorry is jsut that i type to fast

Just* >_>

Aslo you have a point. he cant be sonic kid but he might be related. maybe sonic is just silver grandpa

Sonic 1366 years old, in a nursing home... and Silver won't come to listen to him babble on about super speed and how he was once enemies with the guy he plays Bingo with on Saturdays.--Mystic Monkey 21:55, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

silver looks more sonaze to be honest (compare their picture for evidence) darksonic50

So Silver is his great grandfathers ansestor and lacks the Delta Brainwave or something? Please clarify.--Mystic Monkey 20:16, 4 February 2009 (UTC)

ok i think that sonic and silver r related but silver is lik his great great great great grandchild and may lack of some things, he cant be or look EXACTLY lik sonic. Dawnthehedgehog 15:43, 8 February 2009 (UTC)

I said that. I say it's four or more generations. NOT 1366 years, more like 300. Flashfire212 05:50, 9 February 2009 (UTC) ok,i think sonic and shadow and silver are brothers but when they are was very young eggman nega Tampering the time who is take silver in dimension next 200 years and take shadow in dimension 50 years back because he was think if they all be together they will be stronger than any one elesHedgehogs 22:28, 4 March 2009 (UTC)hedgehogs

It's already been proven that Gerald built Shadow, and Black Doom gave his DNA to Shadow, to get things to work better than Biolizard. Thus, Shadow is a Black Arms soldier / desendant. So it's impossible.
If Sonic, and Silver were brothers, they'd likely both be the same color, have similar powers, etc. Siver can't even be Sonic's desendant. When Mephiles killed Sonic, Silver would've been erased from time. And from my knowledge of time travel, even though Sonic was resurrected, but in a distorted time, that doesn't realy exist (End of the World), Silver still wouldn't exist. Matter of fact, he never would've existed in the first place. So both are now disproven. It's plausible that Silver could be a desendant of Amy, or a future hedgehog character, yet to be introduced. Or we could, y'know, never meet his ancestors. Just wanted to clear that up. Latezzzz SLJCOAAATR the SNN Admin Careful, it's a Faradox 22:58, 4 March 2009 (UTC)

What about shadow? Them two always seem to get along and in arthurian legend, galahad (Silver) is Lacelot's (Shadow) son. Physicaly the two have similarities two. Myself 123 23:17, 4 March 2009 (UTC)

It's plausible, but, when was the last time you saw a robotic alien hedgehog sexually reproduce? SLJCOAAATR the SNN Admin Careful, it's a Faradox 23:28, 4 March 2009 (UTC)

Ok 2 things...1 thats my brother ur talking about and two i think it would be very rare for silver and shadow to be related, i'd say he is sonic decendent besides the color does not matter for all we know sonic's grandcildren could of married a silver hedgehog therefore giving silver his color. Dawnthehedgehog 00:47, 5 March 2009 (UTC)

whoa! i just realised somthing! Shadow's name relates to darkness whilst Silver's names relates to light. Myself 123 15:43, 7 March 2009 (UTC)

What about Silver's PK? It most come from somewhere, so why couldn't it be a variation of Chaos Control, hinting that Shadow and Silver are related?

could be, many assume it just evolution but you never know. Myself 123 16:56, 7 March 2009 (UTC)

Heres a thought! Silver has nothing to do with Sonic or anyone, he is just a hedgehog from the future trying to stop Iblis?--Mystic Monkey 17:06, 7 March 2009 (UTC)
CAREFUL, IT'S A FARADOX SLJ roxrz Just type the numbers every 108 minutes 17:23, 7 March 2009 (UTC)
nah, i like the idea of sonic's battle agaist eggman to be still active in 200 years. Though i have to admit there similarities between shadow and silver, he being sonic's decendant seems more plausable. Myself 123 17:40, 7 March 2009 (UTC)

i agree know your username is very confusing (myself 123).The Chosen One of Fire 18:58, 8 March 2009 (UTC)

By 200 years, Eggman, and Sonic should be long dead. SLJCOAAATR 4 6 8 15 16 23 42 108 305 316 19:36, 8 March 2009 (UTC)
i didn't mean literally. what i ment was thier families are still fighting 200 years in the future. and yes it is confussing, i was trying to find somthing origonal and it was the first thing that came to me. Myself 123 20:21, 8 March 2009 (UTC)

i work on my name for years, and here i get a guy who calls himself 'myself?'The Chosen One of Fire 01:25, 9 March 2009 (UTC)

lol XD Myself 123 17:11, 10 March 2009 (UTC)

My brothers originally had the name "Mystic Monkey" but haven't used it since.--Mystic Monkey 18:45, 10 March 2009 (UTC)

at least it's original.The Chosen One of Fire 12:07, 11 March 2009 (UTC)

Mines so un-origional it's origional. Myself 123 23:16, 13 March 2009 (UTC)

.....It took years to come up with The Chosen One of Fire?......Bleh.
Aaaaaaanyways, I guess that's plausible, Myself. SLJCOAAATR 4 6 8 15 16 23 42 108 305 316 23:57, 13 March 2009 (UTC)

talk about hypocrisy.this guy goes and preaches about no insults, and yet here he is insulting me!The Chosen One of Fire 04:01, 14 March 2009 (UTC)

okk....thats not really an insult....and if this is, then here it goes: your comments are just getting weirder and queerer by the second.,........--The Chosen One of Water 13:18, 14 March 2009 (UTC)

I think they are (at least) distant relatives and don't even know it!!! I think it is very possible.--Akamia 01:23, 16 March 2009 (UTC)

OK, here is the deal. If SIlver was Sonic's descendant, then it would cause a paradox. As, if you've played Sonic 06, Mephiles kills Sonic. Therefore, Silver would not have existed and Mephiles would not have taken him back in time to kill Sonic. Therefore he wouldn't have died and they would've gone back in time and killed him - PARADOX ALERT!!!!!--BloodSonic1 16:20, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

BUZZ!! One more thing. Iblis was released a few hours or days after Sonic met Elise. In Silver's time, Iblis has destroyed a lot, but not enough to indicate even 10 years difference. In 300 years, Iblis would've OBLITERATED the planet. So I think that Sonic and Silver are not related at all. I reckon that Silver is really young in Sonic's time. Say, in the near-future if Sonic, Silver and Shadow had not stopped Solaris, or Mephiles hadn't merged with Iblis, Sonic and co. would probably have continued trying to kill Iblis until most of them die. Then Silver and BLaze step in and continue where Sonic left off, just getting no further. It is assumed that Silver doesn't know anyone from Sonic's time, so we can assume they all died before Silver started fighting Iblis. Blaze, we don't know as we don't see much of her except for her giving Silver advice and crap.

The bottom line is - We don't know. But we can assume from what logic I used that Silver is NOT from 300 years in the future. More like 20 or something...--BloodSonic1 16:34, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

The family lines could have changed after '06, making it possible, but not yet confirmed.--Akamia(Talk)(Want to see what I've been doing?) 06:26, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

Whatever. (-_-')--Akamia(Talk)(Want to see what I've been doing?) 06:37, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

Since I don't really believe in the concept of time, I don't really believe in paradox's. If I went back in time to murder myself for whatever reason, I wouldn't be effected since I would of left my original past behind the moment I intruded into the past. In other words to those who believe time, I would be creating an alternate timeline killing my past self though since I come from an original one I would not be effected, After all, how can you tell if you went all the way to the past to murder yourself if you would of killed yourself to begin with? I believe whats done is done with only history and predictions to let us know whats going on. Also on the subject of Silver being a decendant of our current hedgehog heroes, if he's likea decendant of (lets say) Sonic, then why is it expected that he should beare more resemblence than being a hedgehog? Besides the fact though the line of hedgehogs and perhaps other animals after Sonic, or probably Silver is Sonics kid or grandson, Silver is a white psychic yet slow hedgehog because thats who he is. I am told I look a bit like my father but I am not exactly him.--Mystic Monkey 22:59, 17 May 2009 (UTC)

O.O. w-w-wow. You're one of the few people I have ever met who actually understands time paradoxes!!! Welcome to my world!--Milotheechidna 02:26, 18 May 2009 (UTC)

also, does anyone here know about Zeno's paradox?The Chosen One Of Fire 13:16, 24 May 2009 (UTC)

Is it a philosophy or something based on Sonic?--Mystic Monkey 22:19, 24 May 2009 (UTC)

man, i wish i had a piece of paper right now, it needs to be seen.The Chosen One Of Fire 01:22, 25 May 2009 (UTC)

I think Shadow is more of a possibility, as he is immortal, and can possibly live for 200 Years. Silver's white fur could be from Rouge 'cough' 'laughs' 'cough'-PunchOutJoe- 03:14, 31 May 2009 (UTC)

All i can say is WHOA...Anyway if Silver was a decendent of Shadow he would have a dark side/mysterious side, which silver dosent....On Joe's occasion...well Silver isnt like Rouge except 4 the fur colour. Dawn the Hedgehog 03:51, 3 June 2009 (UTC)

But then again, Sonic and Amy don't look like Silver that much. He has a personality a little like Sonic's, but they certainly don't look like each other. Sonic is blue, Amy is pink. The father or mother would have to be a hedgehog, seeing he's a hedgehog. But maybe the parents aren't even Sonic or Shadow. It could be a whole different hedgehog. Think Sonic Adventure DX style. Tikal looks NOTHING like Knuckles, and neither do those other echindas (that much). BTW, I am talking to support both points.--Cloverfang 14:15, 3 June 2009 (UTC)CLoverfang

I'd have to say if anything Silver is more likely related to Shadow, they both have the chest hair (look at Silver's opening cutscene in Sonic '06 and you can see), and the colored crescents around the sides of their eyes (I don't know what they are called) File:SilvertheHedgehog.png, File:Schan shadow2-1.png. As you can see, Shadow's are red and more near the top, and Silver's are more around the entire sides, and are colored black. Also, Black Doom was capable of hovering, and using some sort of telekinesis (being able to throw meteors at Shadow in StH). At the very least, he has some sort of telepathic abilities, who's to say that couldn't be passed down to Silver? Silver also seemed to be ready to kill someone for the fate of the world (I can't say I see Sonic doing that), that seems more like something that would come from Shadow. Although, personally I don't see how Sonic or Shadow could ever have kids. It's an interesting thought none the less. Also, yes Shadow was built, but how does that not mean he can't have kids? --Yoyoddd 04:08, 16 June 2009 (UTC)

Response to SLJCOAAATR: "When Mephiles killed Sonic, Silver would've been erased from time. And from my knowledge of time travel, even though Sonic was resurrected, but in a distorted time, that doesn't realy exist (End of the World), Silver still wouldn't exist." You gotta remember though, that the events in Sonic '06 were erased from time, so they never happened. It's still possible that Silver is a descendant of Sonic, Shadow, Amy, or the like. --SSRider 22:44, 5 July 2009 (UTC)

Hmmm perhaps Silver is a decendant from..POT!!!! JUST KIDDING (but really what was sega thinking when they did his quills?) Anyway Perhaps he is just a Hedgehog in the future. He could not be Sonic's son though because he's from the 34th or whatever century and we are only in the 21st. Cheetahfly 22:20, 6 July 2009 (UTC)

Well originally, his current look was suppose to be his psychic state when he's levitating and chucking $#!7 around, when not going Psychic it's all suppose to fold over his head. However along the way they decided to keep his hair up and caled him Silver than Venice.--Mystic Monkey 22:42, 6 July 2009 (UTC)

Maybe Silver isn't a descendant from ANY of the hedgehogs. MAYBE he's an ANDROID. An android with telekinetic abilities - OK, that puts a hole in it. Anyways, I reckon Silver is just Silver and it doesnt matter who he's a descendant of. Hes a freaking video game character. i mean, you don't see anyone asking who Amy's parents were or Rouge's parents or, for christ sake, ANYONE ELSES! All this because hes from the fuchar? Please. Who gives a damn?? Why does it even matter? For the last time, ITS A GAME AND IT DOESNT MATTER!!!!!!! I'm too lazy to add everything - Blood

Oh come on! Talking about being personal with your own videogame characters! First fanfiction sucks, then you put stupic forums, then you put stupid couples and now THIS! Silver is a what!? He doesn't need to have a family who is our favorite hero! You fans SUCK!--LonelyAssassin 'Vote My Poll' 10:50, October 27, 2009 (UTC)

Okay, firstly, SlugDrones, you need to chillax. I know you dislike (okay, HATE) fandom but you should try to just ignore it so it dosen't tick you off as much. Secondly, if he were related to Sonic, then when Sonic was killed by Mephiles, Silver wuld have disappered, too! Regardless of Sonic being revived later on, even so, Silver would have disappeared and then reappeared again! -- Shelly the Hedgehog Amy to Shelly 02:57, October 29, 2009 (UTC)

And while Shadow is not invincable. But believe to be immortal so Silver would at least have some clue of him as his father or ancestor. If not then while Shadow was accused of being the Iblis Trigger, he might not of continued his bloodline before his imprisonment by Omega.--Mystic Monkey 15:56, October 29, 2009 (UTC)

Personally, I think that Sonic being Silver's ancestor is more plausable. I think it makes sense since they have similar personalities (both are coky, immature, and have a srtong sense of justice), both are fast characters (this is shown in Sonic Rivals), and they each fight a member of Eggman's family line (which may hint that Sonic and Eggman's family lines continued their ancestors' fight). Besides, people keep missing the fact that Silver never disappeared because Sonic could have been destined to be revived, which meant that Silver couldn't have just disappeared immediately when Sonic was killed. And I think they look more alike than Shadow since Silver's back spines are more like Sonic's (I also think his front spines are somewhat like Amy, which is one reason why I think that Silver could have descended from Sonic and Amy's kids if they have any in the future), and I think the black lines surrounding the sides of Silver's eyes were just meant to make his eyes more visible instead of contrasting with his fur, while the chest fur may be from someone else in Silver's family line other than Shadow, besides, Silver's no Black Arms and he doesn't have the markings of the black arms (red and black), no red eyes, hair style doesn't have any or enough resemblence to Shadow's, and most importaint of all, he does NOT have a cold personality like Shadow (which may be shared with the Black Arms since Black Doom appears to have a cold personality). Either way, I think I have enough proof and reasons to believe that Sonic and Silver may be relaited.  -AlexTheUltimateInovator97 2:35 PM 5/14/2013