|This location exists primarily or exclusively within the Archie Comics continuity.|
Information in this article may not be canonical to the storyline of the games or any other Sonic continuity.
The island was located in 3237 by Sonic the Hedgehog, having discovered the island's blueprints, where upon the badniks decided to prove their abilities by facing off against the hedgehog. Proving no match against him, the badniks then allowed Pseudo-Sonic to face off one-on-one against his organic counterpart. The two bashed heads sending Sonic flying away, the island seemingly destroyed from the collision. After Sonic left, the badniks, having deliberately sunk the island to remain in hiding, set to work on repairing Pseudo-Sonic. (StH: #170)
Some time later, the badniks realized they could enlarge Pseudo-Sonic and make him a much more powerful force. During their efforts to do this, the island came under siege by the Forty Fathom Freedom Fighters. Although the badniks managed to hold off against the aquatic Freedom Fighters until Pseudo-Sonic became much taller and stronger, they were subsequently defeated by Big Fluke, who crushed the badniks and the mechanical island into a giant cube. (StH: #185)
- The name is a spoof of the "Island of Misfit Toys", from the Christmas special Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer.
- As told by the picture, the island is shown to be home to a Burrobot, Crabmeat, Orbinaut, Caterkiller, Jaws, Bat Brain, and Motobug; all badniks that came from the very first Sonic game.
- Motobug and Burrobot are miscolored.