The downsides to the Sonic movie ideas:
Rating: Both of them said that it shoudl be PG-13. It should NOT be PG-13. I know Shadow the Hedgehog was E10+ but that doesn't mean it has to be like that.
Type of film: One of them said it should be live-action. Wow. Just imagine if the directors of the horrilbe Mario movie made a Sonic movie!
Plot: Both plots are pretty useless. That is all.
What needs to be in a Sonic movie:
Rating: It should be PG, like a normal video game movie should.
Type of film: If it just takes place in Sonic's world, then CGI. But if it takes place in the real world, then CGI/live-action.
Plot: Whatever you think it should be.
What I actually agreed on:
One of them said it should be in 2D, Real D 3D and IMAX. That's the only thing I agree on.
And that's all, but remember these are just my opinions. Don't get offended by it.